Publication Ethics

Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

1. Ethical Principles

At-Ta’dib: Journal of Pesantren Education is a peer-reviewed, open-access scholarly journal published by the Faculty of Tarbiyah, University of Darussalam Gontor, Indonesia. The journal is committed to maintaining academic integrity, editorial independence, fairness, transparency, and responsible scholarly communication. This statement outlines the ethical responsibilities of authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher. The journal’s publication ethics policies are informed by the core practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing. All parties involved in the publication process are expected to uphold these principles and cooperate in addressing suspected breaches of publication ethics.

2. Responsibilities of the Publisher

The publisher supports the Editor-in-Chief and editorial team in maintaining the integrity and quality of the journal’s publication process. The publisher is committed to ensuring that editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit and are not improperly influenced by commercial interests, advertising, institutional relationships, or other external pressures. The publisher supports appropriate action when publication misconduct is suspected or established, including corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions when warranted. Editorial decisions remain the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately authorized editor.

3. Editorial Responsibilities

3.1 Publication Decisions

The Editor-in-Chief and authorized editors are responsible for deciding which manuscripts are suitable for publication. Decisions are based on the manuscript’s academic quality, originality, relevance to the journal’s focus and scope, methodological rigor, contribution to scholarship, reviewer reports, and compliance with publication ethics. Editors may consult reviewers and other editorial advisers when making decisions. Editorial decisions must comply with applicable legal requirements, including those relating to copyright, defamation, and research or publication misconduct.

3.2 Fair and Impartial Evaluation

Manuscripts must be evaluated fairly and objectively according to their scholarly merit. Editors must not discriminate against authors on the basis of race, ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, political beliefs, institutional affiliation, or other irrelevant personal characteristics.

3.3 Confidentiality

Editors and editorial staff must maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and related editorial communications. Information about a manuscript may be shared only with individuals who are appropriately involved in its evaluation or publication, or when disclosure is otherwise justified by ethical or legal obligations. Unpublished information obtained through editorial handling must not be used for personal research or advantage without the author’s explicit written permission.

3.4 Conflicts of Interest

Editors must disclose relevant conflicts of interest and avoid handling manuscripts when such conflicts could compromise their impartiality. Where necessary, the manuscript must be reassigned to an independent editor.

3.5 Allegations of Misconduct

Editors must take allegations of research or publication misconduct seriously, whether raised before or after publication. Concerns must be assessed fairly and confidentially, with an opportunity for relevant parties to respond. The journal may consult reviewers, authors, institutions, or other appropriate parties when investigating a concern.

4. Reviewers’ Responsibilities

4.1 Contribution to Editorial Decisions

Peer review assists editors in assessing manuscript quality and helps authors improve their work. Reviewers are expected to provide constructive, evidence-based, and academically relevant assessments.

4.2 Competence and Timeliness

Reviewers should accept assignments only when they have appropriate expertise and can complete the review within the agreed timeframe. They must notify the editor promptly if they are unable to review a manuscript or cannot complete the review on time.

4.3 Confidentiality

Manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not share, reproduce, or discuss manuscript content with unauthorized individuals. Unpublished ideas, data, and findings must not be used for personal or professional advantage.

4.4 Objectivity and Professional Conduct

Reviews must be objective, respectful, and supported by clear reasoning. Personal criticism of authors is inappropriate. Reviewers should identify weaknesses in argumentation, research design, analysis, interpretation, and reporting, as relevant to the manuscript.

4.5 Acknowledgment of Sources

Reviewers should identify relevant published work that has not been cited and alert the editor to substantial similarities or possible overlap with other publications of which they are aware.

4.6 Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must disclose potential conflicts of interest, including relevant personal, professional, financial, or collaborative relationships. They should decline an assignment when a conflict could compromise the impartiality of their assessment.

5. Authors’ Responsibilities

5.1 Reporting Standards and Research Integrity

Authors must present an accurate account of their research, including the methods, evidence, analysis, and conclusions. Data and findings must not be fabricated, falsified, or deliberately misrepresented. Manuscripts must contain sufficient methodological detail and relevant references to support scholarly evaluation.

5.2 Originality and Plagiarism

Authors must submit original scholarly work and appropriately acknowledge the words, ideas, data, and contributions of others. Direct quotations, paraphrases, previously published materials, and reused content must be properly cited and, where necessary, used with permission. The journal screens submissions for text similarity. Similarity reports are assessed contextually and do not, by themselves, establish whether plagiarism has occurred.

5.3 Duplicate and Concurrent Submission

Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to more than one journal. Manuscripts must not contain substantially overlapping publications presented as new and original work without appropriate disclosure, citation, and justification. Any relevant prior publication or related manuscript must be disclosed to the editor.

5.4 Authorship and Contributions

Authorship must reflect substantial scholarly contributions to the conception or design of the research, data collection, analysis or interpretation, or other recognized intellectual contributions to the work. Authors must participate in drafting or critically revising the manuscript, approve the final version, and agree to its submission and publication. All eligible contributors must be appropriately credited, and individuals who do not meet the authorship criteria should be acknowledged where appropriate. The corresponding author is responsible for confirming that all authors have approved the final manuscript and agreed to its submission. Changes to authorship after submission must be explained and approved by all affected authors and the editor.

5.5 Acknowledgment and Funding Disclosure

Authors must acknowledge relevant sources of funding and the contributions of individuals or organizations that supported the research. Financial or non-financial interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing the research or its interpretation must be disclosed.

5.6 Data Availability and Retention

Authors should retain research data and supporting records for a reasonable period and provide them for editorial verification when appropriately requested, subject to applicable ethical, legal, confidentiality, and data-protection requirements. Data-sharing statements should be provided when required by the journal or appropriate to the study.

5.7 Research Involving Human Participants or Animals

Research involving human participants, personal data, or animals must comply with applicable ethical standards and legal requirements. Where required, authors must provide information about ethics committee approval, informed consent, and measures to protect participants’ privacy and confidentiality. Authors must not claim ethical approval or consent that was not obtained.

5.8 Use of Artificial Intelligence

Authors must comply with the journal’s Artificial Intelligence Use Policy. AI tools must not be listed as authors. Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and proper attribution of all content submitted for publication and must disclose AI use when required by the journal’s policy.

5.9 Errors in Published Articles

If authors discover a significant error or inaccuracy in their published work, they must promptly notify the editor and cooperate in determining the appropriate corrective action, which may include a correction or retraction.

6. Similarity Screening and Publication Misconduct

The journal may use Turnitin or an equivalent similarity-checking tool to screen submitted manuscripts. Editorial assessment considers the nature, extent, context, and source of textual overlap, rather than relying solely on a numerical similarity score. Publication misconduct includes, but is not limited to, plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabrication or falsification of data, inappropriate authorship, undisclosed conflicts of interest, citation manipulation, and manipulation of the peer-review process. When misconduct is suspected, the journal assesses the available evidence, seeks clarification from relevant parties when appropriate, and determines the next steps in accordance with the seriousness of the concern and applicable publication ethics guidance. Possible outcomes include rejection, requests for correction, notification of relevant institutions where justified, or post-publication action.

7. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

The journal is committed to maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record. When significant errors or ethical concerns are identified after publication, the editorial team evaluates the evidence and determines whether a correction, expression of concern, or retraction is warranted. Any post-publication notice should clearly identify the affected article, explain the reason for the action, and be linked to the original publication. Retractions are intended to correct the scholarly record and alert readers to unreliable findings; they are not intended solely as punishment for authors.

8. Complaints and Appeals

Authors may raise concerns about editorial procedures or appeal an editorial decision by submitting a reasoned explanation to the journal. Complaints concerning editorial conduct, peer review, or possible ethical violations should be directed to the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriate independent editorial representative. Complaints and appeals are assessed fairly and impartially. Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief or another person directly involved in the matter, it should be referred to an independent and appropriately authorized representative of the publisher. Decisions on complaints and appeals should be documented.

9. Copyright, Licensing, and Publication Charges

The journal’s copyright and licensing arrangements are explained in its separate Copyright and Licensing Policy. Information on publication fees, payment procedures, and any applicable waivers or exceptions is provided in the Article Processing Charge (APC) policy. Publication fees, where applicable, must not influence editorial evaluation or the decision to accept or reject a manuscript.