Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the academic quality, originality, and integrity of At-Ta’dib: Journal of Pesantren Education. Reviewers are expected to evaluate manuscripts objectively, confidentially, and constructively.

1. Review Assignments and Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers should accept assignments only when they have relevant expertise and can complete the review within the specified timeframe. Any potential conflict of interest must be disclosed to the editor. Reviewers should decline assignments when their impartiality may be compromised.

2. Confidentiality

Manuscripts and review materials must be treated as confidential. Reviewers must not disclose manuscript content, use unpublished information for personal advantage, or share manuscripts with unauthorized individuals. Reviewers must also comply with the journal’s Artificial Intelligence Use Policy and protect confidential materials when using digital tools.

3. Review Criteria

Reviewers should assess manuscripts, as appropriate to their type, based on:

  • Relevance to the journal’s focus and scope.
  • Originality and scholarly contribution.
  • Quality of the literature review and theoretical framework.
  • Appropriateness of the research design and methodology.
  • Accuracy of evidence, analysis, and interpretation.
  • Clarity of discussion and conclusions.
  • Research ethics, citation practices, and overall presentation.

4. Constructive Feedback and Ethical Concerns

Reviewers should provide clear, objective, respectful, and evidence-based comments that help authors improve their manuscripts. Feedback should identify major concerns and minor revisions where relevant. Suspected plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, redundant publication, or other ethical concerns should be reported confidentially to the editor, with supporting information where possible.

5. Timeliness and Revised Manuscripts

Reviewers should submit their reports within the deadline provided by the editor. If additional time is needed or the manuscript falls outside their expertise, they should inform the editor promptly. When reviewing a revised manuscript, reviewers should assess whether the authors have adequately addressed the previous comments and recommendations.

6. Recommendations and Final Decisions

Reviewers should provide a reasoned recommendation through the journal’s online submission system. Recommendations may include acceptance, minor revision, major revision, or rejection, depending on the options available in the system. The recommendation should be supported by clear academic reasoning. The final publication decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor. By accepting a review assignment, reviewers agree to uphold the principles of confidentiality, impartiality, academic integrity, and professional conduct.