Peer Review Process

At-Ta’dib: Journal of Pesantren Education applies a peer-review process to evaluate the academic quality, originality, relevance, methodological rigor, and contribution of submitted manuscripts to the field of pesantren education.

Review Model

The journal uses a double-blind review, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to one another during the review process.

Editorial and Review Procedure

All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening to assess their compliance with the journal’s focus and scope, submission requirements, academic standards, and publication ethics. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or rejected before external review.

Manuscripts that pass the initial screening are assigned to an appropriate editor and sent to qualified reviewers with relevant expertise. The journal normally seeks evaluations from two independent reviewers. Reviewers are expected to assess the manuscript objectively and provide constructive feedback on its scholarly contribution, originality, theoretical foundation, research methods, analysis, and conclusions.

Based on the reviewers’ reports and the editor’s assessment, the editor makes a decision to accept the manuscript, request minor or major revisions, or reject it. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the reviewers for further assessment when necessary. The final publication decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor.

Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest

Manuscripts under review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers are expected to provide impartial evaluations, disclose any potential conflicts of interest, and decline assignments when their independence or relevant expertise may be compromised.

Originality and Similarity Screening

At-Ta’dib accepts original scholarly contributions that have not been published previously and are not under consideration for publication elsewhere. Submitted manuscripts are screened for text similarity using Turnitin or an equivalent similarity-checking tool. Similarity reports are assessed by the editorial team in context; a similarity score alone does not determine whether plagiarism has occurred. Suspected plagiarism or other publication-ethics violations are handled in accordance with the journal’s publication ethics policies.