..:: Additional Menu ::..
Corrections, Concerns, and Retractions Policy
Artificial Intelligence Use Policy
1. Policy Statement
At-Ta’dib: Journal of Pesantren Education is committed to maintaining academic integrity and originality in scholarly publishing. All submitted manuscripts must represent original scholarly work, acknowledge the contributions of others appropriately, and comply with accepted standards of research and publication ethics. Plagiarism, including the unattributed use of another person’s words, ideas, data, findings, images, tables, or other intellectual contributions, is unacceptable. The journal also considers inappropriate text recycling, redundant publication, and the unauthorized reuse of previously published material in accordance with the circumstances of each case.
2. Similarity Screening
All submitted manuscripts may be screened using Turnitin or an equivalent text-similarity detection tool during the initial editorial assessment and, where necessary, before publication. A similarity score of 20% or less is used as a screening guideline, not as an automatic determination of originality or an absolute guarantee of compliance. Manuscripts with a score exceeding 20% may be returned to the authors for clarification, revision, or further editorial assessment. A manuscript may also be investigated or rejected when evidence of plagiarism is identified, even if its overall similarity score is below 20%. In evaluating similarity reports, the editorial team considers the sources and locations of matching text, the use of quotations and citations, the similarity of ideas or data, the nature of the reused material, and the overall academic context. Similarity scores are not assessed in isolation.
3. Authors’ Responsibilities
Authors are responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts comply with the following requirements:
1) Originality: Manuscripts must present original scholarly contributions and must not contain plagiarized material.
2) Proper attribution: Words, ideas, data, findings, and materials derived from other sources must be appropriately cited and, where necessary, quoted or used with permission.
3) Text recycling: Authors must disclose and appropriately cite relevant overlap with their own previously published work. Reuse of previously published material must not misrepresent existing work as new or original.
4) Copyright compliance: Authors must obtain permission when required to reproduce copyrighted material, including figures, tables, images, and substantial excerpts.
5) Publication exclusivity: Manuscripts must not be under consideration by another journal at the same time. Previously published work must not be presented as an unpublished original submission.
4. Categories of Plagiarism and Editorial Actions
The journal assesses suspected plagiarism according to the extent and nature of the overlap, the importance of the material involved, the adequacy of attribution, the potential impact on the scholarly record, and the author’s explanation where appropriate.
4.1 Minor Plagiarism
Minor cases may involve limited unattributed wording or an inadequately cited passage that does not involve substantial ideas, data, findings, or other central contributions. Possible action: The editor may request correction, proper citation, or rewriting before further consideration. A warning may be issued when appropriate. The manuscript will proceed only if the issue is satisfactorily resolved.
4.2 Moderate Plagiarism
Moderate cases may involve substantial unattributed passages, repeated instances of inappropriate copying, significant text recycling without adequate disclosure, or the use of another source’s ideas or arguments without appropriate acknowledgment. Possible action: The manuscript may be rejected. Where clarification is necessary, the editor may request an explanation before making a final decision. Further action may be taken in accordance with the journal’s publication ethics policy.
4.3 Severe Plagiarism
Severe cases may involve extensive copying, plagiarism of central ideas or research findings, appropriation of data or results, substantial reproduction of another work without proper attribution, or other serious forms of intellectual misappropriation. Possible action: The manuscript will normally be rejected. For published articles, the journal may issue a correction, expression of concern, or retraction, depending on the findings and their implications for the scholarly record. The journal may also consider restrictions on future submissions or notify the relevant institution when justified by the seriousness of the case and applicable ethical procedures.
5. Procedure for Handling Suspected Plagiarism
When suspected plagiarism is identified, the journal follows a fair and documented process:
1) Initial assessment: The editor examines the similarity report and identifies potentially problematic passages or materials.
2) Verification: The editor reviews the original sources, citations, the nature of the overlap, and the scholarly context.
3) Author clarification: When appropriate, the corresponding author is invited to provide an explanation or relevant supporting information.
4) Editorial decision: The editor determines whether the concern can be resolved through correction or revision, requires further investigation, or warrants rejection or another appropriate action.
5) Documentation and follow-up: The decision and its rationale are documented. Serious cases may be handled under the journal’s broader publication ethics procedures, including appropriate post-publication action where necessary.
6. Plagiarism in Published Articles
If plagiarism is identified after publication, the journal will investigate the matter in accordance with its publication ethics policies. Depending on the severity of the violation and its effect on the reliability and integrity of the published work, the journal may publish a correction, expression of concern, or retraction. The journal may also take other appropriate action in accordance with applicable ethical standards and procedures.
7. Editorial Responsibility
The Editor-in-Chief and authorized editors are responsible for implementing this policy consistently and impartially. All suspected cases are assessed on their individual merits, and editorial actions are based on evidence, the seriousness of the violation, and the need to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record.
..:: Additional Menu ::..
Corrections, Concerns, and Retractions Policy
Artificial Intelligence Use Policy
Kampus Pusat UNIDA Gontor
Jl. Raya Siman Km. 06 Demangan Siman Ponorogo 63471 Jawa Timur
Authors
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Licensed under